The Mental Health Practice - PRINCIPAL - Tammy Groves, Solicitor
RSS

Delivered by FeedBurner


Recent Posts

Review of the Operation of ss.135 and 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983 in England and Wales - April 2014
My heart bleeds when I see vulnerable patients being represented very badly
Do Tribunals love CTOs as much as Psychiatrists do? Part 2
Do Tribunals love CTOs as much as Psychiatrists do?
Patients' experiences of the First-tier Tribunal (Mental Health)

Categories

CTOs Tribunal MP v Mersey Care NHS Trust [2011] UKUT 107 (AAC
Legal aid cuts, Reform of legal aid, House of Commons Justice Committee Report
Patients' experience of Mental Health Tribunals, Report of Administrative Justice and Tribunal's
Qualifications of legal representatives
Review of Mental Health Legislation
RN v CC (2011) UKUT x (AAC, CTOs
S.2, Mental Health Act, Mental Health Law, Tribunal, Application, Tammy Groves,R (Modaresi) v SSH
Zombification, Tony Zigmond, Increase in Admissions under the Mental Health Act 1983, CTOs
powered by

The Mental Health Law Blog

Review of the Operation of ss.135 and 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983 in England and Wales - April 2014

Review of the Operation of ss.135 and 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983 in England and Wales


This article was first published on Lexis®PSL Private Client on 15 April 2014.

 
1.    What are the key sections of the Mental Health Act 1983 that are being reviewed in the consultation?
 
The consultation is reviewing the operation of sections 135 and 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983. This gives the police powers to temporarily remove people, who appear to be suffering from a mental disorder and who need urgent care, to a "place of safety" so that a mental health assessment can be carried out and appropriate arrangements made for their care.  
 
2. What are the problems with the existing law and its enforcement? And what are the main goals of the consultation?
 
Questions have been raised about  the existing law, in particular whether a police station is an appropriate place to detain people suffering from a mental health crisis, especially young people, and whether the maximum length of detention under sections 135 and 136 (72 hours) is too long.
 
The consultation is seeking the views of all those directly affected by s.135 and/or s.136 of the Mental Health Act 1983. This includes individuals who have been detained under these section, and their friends, families and carers, police officers, Approved Mental Health Professionals, and Mental Health Trusts. The goal is to make sure that the legislative framework supports getting the right support for people at the right time, by reviewing the evidence to determine whether or not changes to the primary legislation would improve outcomes for people experiencing a mental health crisis.
 
3. Are there any potential drawbacks to the current legislation?
 
The Code of Practice to the Mental Health Act 1983 states a police station should only be used for those detained under s.136 on an exceptional basis, and that a police station should not be assumed to be the automatic second choice if the first choice place of safety is not immediately available. However the Joint Review in 2013 by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary, Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons, the Care Quality Commission and Healthcare Inspectorate Wales to examine the extent to which police custody is used as a place of safety under s.136 found that the use of police custody remains unacceptably high and that it was still being used as a primary or secondary place of safety. Although they had not committed a crime, the Joint Review found that those detained under s.136 who were taken to a police station were generally treated like any other person in respect of the booking-in procedure; risk assessment; and ultimately, being locked in a cell (rather than being taken to another part of the station). It found that the average time that each person spent in police custody was 10 hours 32 minutes. Many of those detained remarked that their experience had made them feel like criminals, and they described many aspects of the custody process as de-personalising. Other studies have shown that rates of detention under s.136 are higher in the black population, that the police station was a frightening environment as a place of safety,  that there was stigma attached to its use, and where a person was also a victim of crime this was not always taken seriously.
 
4. How could the outcomes of the consultation impact:
 
a)    police powers
There is a very good chance that following the consultation the Mental Health Act 1983  will be amended to remove a police station as a place of safety for those detained under s.136 except on a exceptional basis which will be clearly defined in law.
 
Further amendments may reduce the maximum detention times for those detained in police custody under s.136  - perhaps allowing up  to 24 hours in police custody  which would be more in line with the  detention of those arrested for criminal allegations.
 
It is also likely  that the period of detention will have to be subject to regular independent reviews by both police and health officials to ensure that the detained person can be transferred to a health-based place of safety as soon as possible or that an assessment is carried out at the police station as expeditiously as possible.  
 
The consultation may also result in a police station being deemed to be an inappropriate place of safety for children under 18 years, and in all cases it is probable that the police will be required to record why a person detained under s.136 is at the police station rather than a health-based place of safety.
 
b) lawyers advising clients in this area?
Lawyers should be aware that the consultation follows the important case of MS v United Kingdom (2012) 55 EHCC 23.  This involved an individual who had been detained for some 75 hours in police custody  due to delays in completing an assessment of their mental health.   The European Court of Human rights found that the treatment of the individual was degrading, and so they had been subjected to a violation of their rights under Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. This means that a successful claim can be brought under Article 3 by an individual who is detained in police custody for a prolonged period, and  where the police station is an unsuitable place for them, even where the detention would be lawful under the Mental Health Act 1983.
5. Final comments
This consultation is to be welcomed, although it is long overdue. I have had many clients who have complained of how, although they had committed no crime, they were handcuffed  and carted off to the police station in front  of their neighbours, and then left in a cell for hours while  their mental state steadily deteriorated. The use of the police station as a place of safety is more likely  to escalate a mental health crisis, and police officers are ill-equipped to deal effectively with these situations.  I look forward to positive changes in mental health legislation being brought about as a result of the consultation, so that those in crisis are assessed in an appropriate environment as quickly as possible.
 
 
Tammy Groves, Solicitor
The Mental Health Practice

14/04/14

36 Comments to Review of the Operation of ss.135 and 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983 in England and Wales - April 2014:

Comments RSS
The Dark Knight Rises Bane Mantel Jacke on 03 May 2014 09:09
Radically information man. I should come again to check this again when I’m free.
Reply to comment
 
siddika on 22 February 2015 04:37
Regrettably, educators right now tend to be bogged straight down together with mixture mind-numbing duties that could be much better fitted to a good off-the-shelf automatic system. Tasks for example facts checking, exposure and record trying to keep are done hand.best research papers on www.grabmypaper.com for all kind of papers writing and it is very essay from others any writing service providers.


digital aerial repair service on 14 June 2014 17:27
This counsel is to be invited, despite the fact that it is long past due. I have had numerous customers who have grumbled of how, in spite of the fact that they had perpetrated no wrongdoing, they were bound and hauled away to the police headquarters in front of their neighbors, and afterward left in a cell for quite some time while their mental state consistently weakened.
Reply to comment


Kathleen J. Kelly on 01 July 2014 14:33
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can’t wait to read lots of your posts It was certainly interesting for me to read that article. Thanx for it. I like such topics and anything that is connected to this matter. I definitely want to read more on that blog soon.
Reply to comment


masters dissertation in uk on 07 July 2014 18:58
its a lovely web site ,i would like it , I am glad that you simply shared this helpful information with us. iwill be back soon.
Reply to comment
 
bulk sms india on 21 August 2014 07:02
Excellent read, I just go to a friend who was doing research on this topic.


Ross on 21 August 2014 11:11
I just need to specify I'm amateur to weblog and genuinely relished your site page. Likely I'm liable to bookmark your site. You totally accompany marvelous stories. With a debt of gratitude is in order regarding uncovering your site.
Reply to comment


replica watches on 29 August 2014 09:12
Not only do they protect you from the sun, it also protects you from the reflections of swiss replica watches , water, or glass. firms responding to a 2012 survey indicated that they intend to develop clouds using mainframes as an integral part of their cloud services. This is one way to ensure that while one part of the image is being changed the rest remain the same.
Reply to comment


cash advances on 30 August 2014 23:43
US Payday money enhancements inside Il has different home loan alternatives just to be sensible and, Payday money upgrades, Pay day propel notwithstanding Size Financial advances, together with Auto Strategy Financial credits. Most individuals target supporting you decide to purchase the right home loan products and administrations that can aid you to satisfy your individual efficient wishes.
Reply to comment


Debt Collection Singapore on 05 September 2014 20:43
I also plan to do my Masters from Singapore. Your experience was very useful!
Reply to comment


kunagoes on 07 September 2014 08:52
There are some cases, in which people with mental disorders should be handled by police. Because they are in the certain level of mental disorders can harm other people around him, even can commit murder in uncontrolled mental state. But I also don't agree that they must be handled roughly. The best choice is in medical treatment and psychological.
Reply to comment
 
Jeanne H on 13 October 2014 12:39
No one needs to pay longer time than required in jail. A bail bonds service guarantees the court that you're going to show up for the fixed dates. If you do not, a bail agent will find you to make sure that you are present.


PIC Claim on 09 September 2014 17:28
Thanks a ton for writing such a informative blog. I am waiting for your next blog. Keep Writing...
Reply to comment


online astrology on 15 September 2014 12:42
After read a couple of the articles on your website these few days, and I truly like your style of blogging.
Reply to comment


reflexology courses on 16 September 2014 10:22
I trully appretiate your work and tips given by you is helpful to me. I will share this information with my family & friends. wow great i have read many articles about this topic and everytime i learn something new i dont think it will ever stop always new info , Thanks for all of your hard work!
Reply to comment


payday loans chicago on 20 September 2014 22:29
Payday money improvements, Salaryday what's more Fitting Personal credits, at the side of auto began Personal advances. a large portion of us target helping you pick the right home loan item and administrations to guide you to fulfill your temperate needs.
Reply to comment


assignment writing on 26 September 2014 17:26
In all their three degrees, the actual ISEE contains three elements: carefully constructed along with consistent verbal along with quantitative reason tests that will measure ability pertaining to mastering; reading through knowledge along with mathematics success tests offering specific specifics of a student's advantages along with weak spots throughout these locations.
Reply to comment


www on 09 October 2014 07:58
A beneficial professional appreciates everything that he has been performing and do not fall short us often have also your personal being put in simply by pro's with web page.
Reply to comment


write my essay on 10 October 2014 20:35
I am agree with Mental Health Act-1983. We should obtain this act for our society. We should follow this rules to keep well our mental health. Thanks you for this post.
Reply to comment


Seimon on 12 October 2014 12:46
The ability to accurately customize curriculum to the individual has been the holy grail of educational philosophy for many years. This golden age of technological development may soon enable this dream to become a reality.http://www.solutionsinwriting.org/ can help us more for the quality writing services.
Reply to comment


hand reflexology course on 18 October 2014 11:28
Thanks for remind us about this important issue in operation of mental health...You are just too true to be good. How do you manage to write and research on such wonderful things? You have inspired me to work harder now. !!!!!!!!!!
Reply to comment


http://www.essaywriting-service.org on 22 November 2014 20:36
At the very 1st, I’d favor to state thanks to you for this enlightening article. Second, I'd prefer to wonder wherever I can learn a lot more info concerning your post. I arrived right here via Bing and can't discover any associated web websites connected to this matter. How do I sign for your web blog? I had prefer to stick to your updates as they arrive along! I'd a query to interrogate but I forgot what it absolutely was... anyways, thank you very much.__)))
Reply to comment


first aid course london on 24 November 2014 12:05
There many spectacular factors in your blog site. I have to value your own outstanding operate. Not simply it offered me personally having facts but in addition features offered me personally fun my partner and i had been searching for.
Reply to comment


Forklift Training Melbourne on 25 November 2014 17:54
Thanks for sharing this. This would be a big help but I think writing an essay for college application needs only determination. If you are determined enough to enter college.
Reply to comment


LV iPhone 6 Plus Cases on 16 December 2014 16:03
With the top Samsung phones, assessing power isn't always just a case of looking at one CPU. Both the Note 3 and Note 4 come in different variations that use Qualcomm Snapdragon processors and Samsung’s own Exynos ones.
Reply to comment


Anonymous on 03 March 2015 10:49
Reply to comment


strona www on 03 March 2015 10:50
More energy model allow you and me to dedicate yourself according to big load Enhancing section is commonly limited by choose the types of floor
Reply to comment


nstallment loan waukegan on 28 March 2015 11:16
Some of the Sanctuary Lawful Finance views say that they do not have anything to grumble about this organization and the process that they need to be approved. They were even amazed that all it needs is just a day of handling and on the next day they were able to get their sources via Western Collaboration.
Reply to comment


check cashing on 03 August 2015 08:51
Your first step should be to understand the best rate of payday credit on offer. Whichever payday credit connection you may pick you must fathom what will be the settled aggregate that you will owe in the wake of completing your payday advance.
Reply to comment


pharmacy bulk supplier on 05 August 2015 14:12
Nice information. All of us have different stages of mind and mental abilities.
Reply to comment


pharmacy dropship on 07 August 2015 11:31
appreciable work. With the changing environment changes are taking place in the laws and regulations as well.Interesting blog .
Reply to comment


Kaylee on 14 April 2016 23:21
I simply need to determine I'm beginner to weblog and really savored your webpage page. Likely I'm subject to bookmark your site. You thoroughly go with great stories. With an obligation of appreciation is all together in regards to revealing your site. Thanks!
Reply to comment


Suborna on 22 May 2016 21:46
There are some cases, in which individuals with mental issue ought to be taken care of by police. Since they are in the specific level of mental issue can hurt other individuals around him, even can submit murder in uncontrolled mental state. In any case, I likewise don't concur that they should be taken care of generally. The best decision is in medicinal treatment and mental. Thank you so much.
Reply to comment


calgary mobile website development on 30 June 2016 06:53
Your main pace should be to appreciate the most excellent rate of payday praise on present. either payday credit link you may pick you have to fathom what will be the established total that you will be indebted in the wake up up of implementation your payday go forward.
Reply to comment


buy Viraday Online on 27 March 2017 10:49
Great information given in the blog. many people will get benefit from this.It clears doubts of many people.
Reply to comment


aurorganic on 26 August 2017 10:48
nice post.It's really helpful... plz see below link: Buy Wheatgrass powder Buy Wheatgrass powder online
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website provided by  Vistaprint
Website
provided by Vistaprint